Student loan debt has become a significant financial burden for millions of Americans, with many struggling to keep up with payments. While bankruptcy can offer relief for various types of debt, student loans occupy a unique and often misunderstood position in bankruptcy law.
This post will explore the relationship between student loans and bankruptcy, providing you with crucial information to navigate this complex issue.
Contrary to popular belief, filing for bankruptcy does not automatically eliminate student loan debt. In fact, student loans are one of the few types of debt that typically survive bankruptcy.
This special treatment stems from changes to bankruptcy law enacted in 1976 and further tightened in subsequent years.
The special treatment of student loans in bankruptcy is rooted in several factors. Public policy plays a significant role, as the government aims to ensure the stability of the student loan system and protect taxpayer interests.
Unlike mortgages or car loans, student loans aren’t secured by any asset that can be repossessed, making them a riskier proposition for lenders. Additionally, education is seen as an investment that provides lifelong benefits, which justifies stricter repayment requirements in the eyes of policymakers.
While student loans are generally non-dischargeable, there is an exception known as the “undue hardship” provision. If you can prove that repaying your student loans would cause undue hardship, you may be able to have them discharged in bankruptcy. However, meeting this standard is notoriously difficult.
Most courts use the “Brunner Test” to determine undue hardship. This test requires you to demonstrate three things: First, based on your current income and expenses, you cannot maintain a minimal standard of living for yourself and your dependents if forced to repay the loans.
Second, this financial situation is likely to persist for a significant portion of the repayment period. Third, you have made good-faith efforts to repay the loans.
Meeting the undue hardship standard is challenging for several reasons. Courts interpret “undue hardship” very strictly, often requiring extreme circumstances. The process involves filing an “adversary proceeding,” which is essentially a lawsuit within your bankruptcy case, adding time and expense. Furthermore, different judges may interpret the standards differently, leading to inconsistent outcomes.
The treatment of student loans in bankruptcy has been a topic of ongoing debate and potential reform. Some judges and legislators have called for a re-evaluation of the strict standard for discharging student loans.
Various bills have been introduced in Congress to make it easier to discharge student loans in bankruptcy, though none have become law as of 2024.
In 2023, the Department of Education issued new guidance to determine when it will recommend the discharge of federal student loans in bankruptcy, potentially making the process easier for some borrowers.
This guidance suggests a shift towards a more flexible approach, but its full impact remains to be seen.
Even if you can’t discharge your student loans, bankruptcy may still offer some relief. Chapter 7 bankruptcy, while typically not discharging student loans, can eliminate other debts, freeing up money to pay student loans. It can also provide a temporary pause on collections during the bankruptcy process.
Chapter 13 bankruptcy can offer several benefits for student loan borrowers. It allows you to reorganize your debts and create a 3-5 year repayment plan, which may reduce payments on student loans during the plan period. It can help you catch up on delinquent payments and stops collections actions, including wage garnishment.
Navigating student loans and bankruptcy is complex and highly dependent on individual circumstances. It’s crucial to seek professional advice. An experienced bankruptcy attorney can evaluate your situation and advise on the best course of action.
Specialists in student loan law can provide targeted advice on managing your student debt. Additionally, a credit counselor can help you understand your options and develop a comprehensive financial plan.
When dealing with student loans and considering bankruptcy, several long-term factors should be kept in mind. While bankruptcy severely impacts your credit score, continuing to default on student loans can also have long-lasting negative effects.
Some professions may be affected by bankruptcy filings, so consider potential career impacts. It’s important to consider how your decision will affect long-term goals like homeownership or retirement savings.
Chronic financial stress can take a toll on your mental health. Sometimes, taking action, even if it’s difficult, can provide relief. It’s essential to consider the emotional aspect of your financial decisions and seek support when needed.
While the overall landscape remains challenging, some recent court decisions have shown a willingness to discharge student loans in certain circumstances.
In 2020, a Navy veteran had $220,000 in student loans discharged due to service-related health issues. In 2021, a 67-year-old woman had over $350,000 in student loans discharged based on her age and limited earning potential.
These cases, while not typical, demonstrate that courts may be becoming more open to considering individual circumstances in student loan bankruptcy cases.
They provide a glimmer of hope for borrowers facing extreme hardship, though it’s important to remember that these cases are still the exception rather than the rule.
Dealing with student loan debt in the context of bankruptcy is a complex and often frustrating process. While the general rule remains that student loans are not dischargeable, exceptions do exist, and the legal landscape continues to evolve.
If you’re struggling with student loan debt, it’s crucial to explore all available repayment options and alternatives before considering bankruptcy. If you do consider bankruptcy, understand that it’s not an easy path for student loan discharge, but it may offer other forms of relief.
Seeking professional advice is essential to understand how bankruptcy might apply to your specific situation.
Stay informed about changes in laws and policies, as the treatment of student loans in bankruptcy may continue to evolve. Remember, while the road may be difficult, you’re not alone in facing these challenges.
With the right information and professional guidance, you can make informed decisions about managing your student loan debt and work towards a more stable financial future.
Dealing with bankruptcy doesn’t have to be a single-person job. The bankruptcy lawyers at Parker & DuFresne will help you determine the best course of action to help you get out from under your debt and move forward to a debt-free future.
Call today at 904-733-7766 for a free consultation, or click the button at the top of the page to schedule online.
Parker and DuFresne
